Thursday, February 27, 2014

Bald eagles transform their lives at 40! - Fact or Fiction

Myth or Fact: Bald eagles go through a process of transformation at 40. They take a life changing decision in which the bald eagle breaks off it's beak and rips off it's feathers. And then waits for them to grow back. This painful procedure takes a good 5 months but it extends an eagle's life from 30years to an amazing 70years! 




Fact or Fiction?

For almost half a decade this has been a topic of debates and discussion. People have argued for and against it without having concrete proofs. So here are a few proofs that we have collected and hopefully they will help you decide for yourself.


A Myth / Rumor? 

 Majority people and mostly the not-so-good observers consider this whole thing to be a simple rumor. According to them, it all began when a few motivational speakers came up with an idea to use this Bald eagle's popularity and supremacy and transform it into something more. They created power-point presentations and slides mainly for the objective on inspiring people in their lectures since people tend to get motivated more from nature. However not long after, these slides became viral over the Internet. People started liking and sharing these slides and it became a topic of widespread discussion. After all the idea of shedding old feathers and growing new ones looks amazing!

Below is one of the slides that became viral showing the transformation of eagles.





People further started to dismiss the idea of this transformation being real when University of Minnesota's Raptor Center stated


"We have received quite a few e-mails regarding the "Eagle Rebirth" story recently. The story is quite far from what an eagle's life truly consists of, but we would be happy to share with you the natural history of the Bald Eagle. Eagles would not typically "lose" their beak or talons, unless it was the result of a traumatic injury. The talons and beak are two of the three best defining features of what makes these birds "raptors". Without the sharp talons for catching prey and the strong, sharp beak for tearing food, the raptor would certainly die of starvation. An eagle hatches with both a beak and talons and these will continue to grow throughout the bird's life. The beak and talons are composed of hard
keratin and are somewhat similar to human fingernails. The talons of the eagle are not flexible as the story claims. New layers of keratin growth build onto the old layers ensuring a strong structure for the raptor. The raptor keeps the beak in good condition naturally in the wild by eating tough prey and rubbing the beak clean on stones or other hard surfaces (feaking) after eating.



Eagles and other raptors generally do not pluck out their feathers. All birds, including raptors, do go through a process of losing feathers and this is called a molt. A bird's feathers do suffer regular wear and tear so, ultimately, the quality of the feather will decrease and it will need to be replaced. The feathers are not lost all at the same time. If this were true, the bird would be unprotected from natural elements and more importantly it would not be able to fly. Eagles and all other raptors need to fly in order to hunt and survive so the loss of flight would most likely mean starvation for the bird. Each feather comes from a feather follicle much like hair does on a mammal. When the feather is first emerging and developing it has a blood supply coming from the body going up into the shaft of the feather. If this feather is broken or pulled out it is not only very painful for the bird, but could result in blood loss and damage to the feather follicle. Severe damage to the feather follicle could result in the permanent loss of the follicle. If a feather is lost before a molt it could take up to a year to be replaced. Raptors and all other birds molt in a symmetrical pattern. If a primary feather is molted on the left wing, the same feather is molted simultaneously on the right wing. This can ensure balance in flight for the bird while it hunts during this molting period.


The average life span of an eagle is approximately 30 years. The eagle, like many other living organisms, does not have the luxury of making the decision to extend their life cycle far beyond what is normal for its species. In captivity, an eagle may live beyond what the average life expectancy is, because it receives both regular and nutritious meals, has access to veterinary care and can be sheltered from the harsh elements by housing provided by the facility caring for the bird. Even then, the life span is in no way extended as far as this myth is suggesting.



There is speculation as to the origin of this myth, but we can assure you that none of it is true."


Further detailed analysis of this slides reveals a few weak points and possibly mistakes.According to the story, to be "reborn" at forty, the eagle must retreat to its nest on a mountain top, first knock off and then regrow its beak, then pluck out and regrow its talons and, finally, pluck out and regrow its feathers, a process that takes 150 days. Thus renewed, the eagle can take its "flight of rebirth" and go on to live another thirty year.


Firstly Bald eagles typically live between twenty and thirty years in the wild. The lifespan of other species of eagles may vary, although none are known to reach seventy years in the wild.

Secondly scientists have studied eagles of various species for generations and much has been published about them, no credible sources back up the "eagle rebirth" story in any way. There are, however, plenty of reliable sources that dismiss the story as a foolish hoax.

In some slides, the eagle shown in the photographs is a Bald Eagle, but in others a different species, the Golden Eagle, is shown. The story also sprouts the scientifically meaningless claim that "the eagle has the longest life-span of its species". The author perhaps meant to say that eagles live longer than all other kinds of birds, but this is also incorrect. Parrots and other species of birds are known to live longer than eagles.


And the most oblivious flaw is as clear as it gets.How can an eagle survive 5 months without hunting for food and water?



Is that all ?

No. Obviously the world can't believe something which is purely a lie. There are a few points which make us ponder over the possibility of all of this being true. Although few but they are pretty impactful and hence can't be simply ignored.


First the authors who claim to have spread this news say that an eagle requires very minimal amount of food during those 5 months of transformation since all it does is to sit on the very exact spot all day long. Hence even food as small as few mice can make eagle survive such a long amount of time.

Possible? Yes, given the fact that the eagle's actions are restricted its all possible scientifically.


Secondly the last 40 years have been good for the Bald Eagle. Back in 1967 it was one of the first North American birds to be put on the 'Endangered Species' list. Its classification has been relaxed to threatened, and to its present status of protected. Along with this its life expectancy has grown and in some cases eagles have grown to be over 70years although rare. Can these eagles have taken the flight of rebirth?

Thirdly people all over the world have seen eagles banging their beaks on hard rocks, which is exactly how the process of transformation starts. Scientist argue that the eagles bang their beaks to sharpen them but still a faint possibility of a start of transformation.


Bottom line:

Be it a hoax or a fact, but we as humans have a lot of things to learn from this flight. We need to be in a process of constant change and adaptation in order to succeed in life.





24 comments:

  1. I knew when I watched that video that it couldn't be fact. A good life lesson but still a myth not fact.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This bird is God's creation and the bible speaks of this bird he is use in scripture, and as a part of Gods creation, this thing,
    what you call a myth is a spiritual revelation from God. I will at anytime and always accept spiritual revelations over man scientist hypothesis.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eagle IS part of God's creation, right. And so is the Bible. And yes, it makes illustrative use of eagle for its ability to see far, also for the particular way it trains its small ones carrying them on its back etc.

      But this particular story is nowhere found in the Bible. And mind you, the Bible doesn't condemn human powers of observation -- this gift of God. It calls a man wise who can tell lies from truth... and certainly the decisive factor is not whether you like the story or not. Sure enough, the most wicked lies are very appealing to human beings -- or else they wouldn't be so dangerous, don't you see?

      With eagles, though, it's easier. Given all the modern mobile devices that make the observation of even such creatures as eagles much easier...

      Delete
    2. God's Word says ..."they that wait upon the Lord, shall renew their strength -- as the Eagles"; I believe HIM not sceptics .

      Delete
    3. is this story in relation to Psalm 103:5?

      Delete
    4. No... They that wait upon the Lord shall renew their strength. They shall mount up on wings as eagles... etc.

      Delete
  3. Unfortunately, non of it is true!! Eagles don't go through any change to live longer!! Sorry!! The average life span of an eagle is approximately 30 years!! You can read more about it here!!
    http://www.snopes.com/critters/wild/eaglerebirth.asp

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for the article, kind of had a feeling that was the case ;)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have been trying to let people know this work of fiction, seen on YouTube is false!! Thanks so much for telling the truth!! Will share.....

    ReplyDelete
  6. nice share about eagle, do you have any story about eagle around the world?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Why disappoint people, this is an amazing story that'll give people hope and motivation. That's what we want to hear. The video is amazing though. It makes me want to jump and start the process of change of the miserable life I'm living.

    ReplyDelete
  8. It's an allegory for crying out loud. Take it for what it is... an inspiring and motivational message. If everyone put that effort into themselves rather than to discredit others the world would be a better place.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well one thing is true eagles do renew their feathers over time. Not all at once like the video showed. Change happens slowly and you can't expect it to happen all at once.

      Delete
  9. Its as simple as this: eagles don't flap and clap their wings unnecessarily but instead waits on the air pockets to support their flight without flappin and clappin and by doing this renews it's strength!! Likewise we should do: instead of flappin and clappin ( like some of you are doing) find strength in the way of the Lord...it's easier.

    ReplyDelete
  10. There's a big difference between being positively inspirational and making up outright lies to motivate people. You can inspire with the truth, easily, it's not necessary to spread stupidity to do it. The whole problem with doing that sort of thing is that there's no line drawn and the world becomes full of misinformation - if you can justify it for eagles then you can justify it for everything and the world declines ever further into confusion and disagreement. it's time to grow up, sooner rather than later.

    Also, they DO NOT carry their babies around on their backs. They're birds, not cargo planes.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I posted the story on my FB page as it had a message and then realised my foolishness and did a reality check.....THE INFORMATION IS JUST EXAGGERATION AND COMPLETELY WRONG.......One post says it's from Kabeer Baqafi......The reality is our moulanas simply use motivational techniques to attract people simply quoting stories without checking their veracity. This is a best example of fooling people with oratory skill............. No eagle lives upto 70 years....their life span is about 20 years...

    ReplyDelete
  12. Well whatever, it served the purpose. Which was to motivate, get you inspired. Y'all just a joy killer criticizing everything!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Motivational speakers can use examples of lizards that regrow cut tails, or snakes who change their skin to continue living. Why invest a lie with eagles?

    ReplyDelete
  14. psalms 103:4-5

    ReplyDelete
  15. it must be true palms psalms 103:4-5

    ReplyDelete
  16. Very perfect for most of the people.Because in human beings it is said 40 is naughty.

    ReplyDelete